top of page

Dreamy Baked Mac & Cheese Recipe

22 hours ago
4 min read

Updated: 36 minutes ago


I've been on the mission for a mac and cheese recipe that matched the essence of what my grandma Florida was able to do for decades. I can't say this is the exact replica but what I vividly remembered was the simple Ingredients she used to create something so famous within our family. This Inspired me to go on a journey on rediscovering how, In a world of Tiktok recipes with a million Ingredients driven by trying to beat the algorithm, or to sound so outrageous you have to just watch to see what the commotion Is about, simplicty is the move.


I ended up digging Into my storage and rediscovering this William-Sonoma cookbook I got at a yard sale simply called "Potato" that came out In 2002. I flipped through the book and one thing I noticed were how simple the recipes were. I ended up cooking a recipe from the book, Potato Gratin, and this Inspired the base of this very mac and cheese recipe and took me back to the simplicity of my grandmother's mac and cheese.


Mac and cheese nowadays (not judging at all) will have garlic and onion and smoke paprika and rosemary and a conglomerate of spices. I did that the past few years and definitely ended up with garlic mac and cheese or a rosemary mac and cheese. That's not what I was going for, I thought. But back to the Potato Gratin recipe - It Interestingly used only salt, pepper, and fresh grated nutmeg. I was super skeptical because I associated nutmeg with french toast, pumpkin spice and In my mind nutmeg = cinnamon. Thats not the case at all. Ladies and gents, lemme Introduce you to FRESH nutmeg.


The flavor Is NOT the same as pre-grounded nutmeg, something about grating nutmeg or cracking peppercorns brings out the natural essential oils and the freshness contained within the pod of a whole nutmeg or a drupe of a peppercorn. Nutmeg Isn't sweet, the point I guess Is to toss out any presumptions of nutmeg you may have.


Now why do I suggest boiling the noodles with water and milk? I was actually re-inspired by the story of the creation of the Mac and Cheese we enjoy here In the US, chef James Hemings. James was the brother of Sally Hemings and the formerly enslaved by Thomas Jefferson. He brought his culinary knowledge from France and brought It over to the US to create a dish to impress the guests of Thomas Jefferson. This is the origins of Mac and Cheese.




Now to this recipe, boy Is It dreamy, creamy, SIMPLE, FRESH, and sure to have people wanting seconds, thirds, and a plate to-go. In a world full of tiktok recipes, and marry me this or that, sometimes something so simple wows the crowd and your tastebuds. Don't underestimate the complexity of your tastebuds, overpowering them Isnt the way to go. Trust me on this!




INGREDIENTS

1/2 lb dried large macaroni elbows (or pasta of choice)

Half water and half milk liquid for boiling pasta

2 tbsp butter (salted or unsalted)

2 tbsp flour

1 1/2 cup half & half, reserve 1/2 cup for thinning If needed

1 cup heavy cream

salt to taste

black pepper, freshly cracked, to taste* (even better If you have fresh cracked white peppercorns)

1/4th tsp freshly grated nutmeg*

8oz block sharp cheddar, grated (reserve 1/2 cup of grated cheese)**

8 oz block mild cheddar, grated (reserve 1/2 cup of grated cheese)**



INSTRUCTIONS

  1. PREHEAT oven to 350 degrees F. In a large stock pot, on HIGH HEAT, boil water and milk mixture. Generously salt mixture. This mixture will try to boil over - to prevent It from boiling over, as soon as It boils, turn temperature to MEDIUM. Add pasta and cook to al dente as instructed on pasta packaging. For example, if packaging says to cook 9 to 11 minutes, cook to 9 minutes.

  2. When pasta Is done cooking, using a coriander, DRAIN noodles and immediately RINSE noodles to stop the cooking process. Reserve noodles.

  3. In a large saucer pan HEAT to medium heat. When thoroughly heated, add butter and melt until It sizzles but not browning. If browning, the pan is too hot. Once the butter is melted and sizzling, add flour and WHISK until well combined about 1 minute. This allows the raw flour taste to cook out.

  4. ADD 1 cup of half and half and immediately WHISK to combine. ADD heavy cream. ADD more half & half if too thick. ADD in salt and freshly cracked pepper. ADD in freshly grated nutmeg. Adjust to taste - this sauce should taste well balanced before adding cheese. Its extremely important that the nutmeg and black pepper is freshly grated and cracked for the flavor profile!

  5. Allow mixture to cook about 2-3 minutes until It thickens a bit. TURN OFF heat and Immediately add In freshly grated cheese. Same thing applies here - It is very important that the cheese is freshly grated!

  6. ADD IN pasta and gently combine Into the sauce mixture. SPOON mixture Into baking dish. Sprinkle the reserved cheese on top of the mac and cheese. BAKE for 15 minutes until cheese Is melted. For a lightly crisp top, BROIL on HIGH about 2 minutes.

  7. Allow to cool at least 10 minutes before serving!


FOOTNOTES

*I cannot emphasize this enough trust me and get a grater and freshly grate the nutmeg on the smallest teeth. Don't use pre-grounded nutmeg, It wont be the same!! Please use freshly cracked black pepper, It wont be the same! Please use freshly grated cheese, It wont be the same! Pre-shredded cheese has an anti-caking agent that can prevent the shreds from melting.

** I HIGHLY recommend Tillamook cheese, It just melts and tastes so much better or a good quality cheese!



 
 
 

Comments


wanna be in the know?
subscribe for exclusive offers, priorities, and more!

thank you! : )

bottom of page